Selective Plating vs. Tank Plating
You know what electroplating is. You know your component can be (brush) selective plated or tank plated. But why choose brush plating over tank, or vice versa? In the chart below we discuss the characteristics that are associated with each method.
|Characteristics||SIFCO Process®||Tank Plating|
|Precision Build-up||Excellent||Fair to Good|
|Deposit Density||Very dense. (25% less porous than tank, 70% less porous than flame spray)||Moderately dense|
|Deposition Rate||Many SIFCO ASC’s solutions can be deposited at rate as high as 0.015” thickness per hour.||Tank plating has a slower deposition rate of .001” thickness per hour.|
|Bond Quality||Excellent (see our blog on bonds)||Good|
|Risk of Hydrogen Embrittlement||SIFCO ASC offers low hydrogen embrittlement cadmium and zinc-nickel for high strength steel. These deposits do not require a bake after plating.||High strength steel plated with Cadmium or Zinc-Nickel will require baking after plating.|
|Post Machining||Usually not required||Usually required|
|Lead Time||The SIFCO Process® has shorter lead times than tank plating due to faster deposition rates, less masking, and in-situ processing.||Tank plating requires disassembly and shipping and handling. Extensive masking may also be required.|
|Portability||The SIFCO Process® is a portable plating process that can be used in the shop or on-site.||Typically limited to the shop.|
|Flexibility||Selective plating can be used on a wide variety of shapes and sizes of parts; including holes as small as 1/4” in diameter with limited masking.||Depending on the component, extensive masking may be required.|
|Safety||The SIFCO Process® uses small quantities of plating solutions which reduces hazardous waste and requires less Personal Protective Equipment or ventilation.||Tank baths require large quantities of solution that need to be maintained and ventilated. Tanks also generate large amounts of hazardous waste when disposed of.|
For questions about what method is right for you, contact us at firstname.lastname@example.org or 800-765-4131.